I’ve been trying to decide over the past week which are Sinatra’s greatest movie songs – and thought I’d pose it as a question, since there are still many of his films I haven’t seen, so I can’t come up with any definitive answers! I’d love to hear other people’s thoughts and recommendations. I found a website which has a list of all the songs he performed in films. By the look of it, this isn’t complete, since I immediately noticed that Three Coins in the Fountain was missing – presumably because he just sang it uncredited over the opening titles.
Anyway, here’s a list of five that I love at the moment, in my current order of preference, which can change from day to day. I also love all his songs in Pal Joey and All the Way in The Joker Is Wild.
5. I Fall In Love Too Easily (Anchors Aweigh, 1945): – For me this ballad by Sammy Cahn and Jule Styne is a real standout scene in Anchors Aweigh – up there with Gene Kelly’s famous dance with Jerry Mouse! Sinatra’s acting might be a little awkward at times in this film, but he really comes into his own here.
4. Guys and Dolls (Guys and Dolls, 1955): This is my favourite musical of all time – I love seeing it on stage and am also a fan of the film, despite all the controversy over Marlon Brando’s casting. Since he played Nathan Detroit rather than Sky Masterson, Sinatra didn’t get to sing some of the greatest songs in Frank Loesser’s score, including Luck Be a Lady – though he later recorded them anyway. However, he does perform the film’s title song, together with Stubby Kaye and Johnny Silver, and also does a great job on Sue Me and Adelaide.
3. Well, Did You Evah? (High Society, 1956): As an admirer of both Sinatra and Bing Crosby, I like hearing them sing this patter song together, with its witty Cole Porter lyric and the great moment where Sinatra jokes “Don’t dig that kind of crooning, chum!” This is another film where Sinatra missed out on the best song, True Love – and sadly I don’t think he recorded it at all. I love Crosby’s version but would have liked to hear Sinatra’s take on this one too.
2. Three Coins in the Fountain (Three Coins in the Fountain, 1952): I must admit that I haven’t seen this film as yet, but I’m really hoping it lives up to Sinatra’s romantic crooning of the title song by Sammy Cahn and Jule Styne. It makes me want to pay a visit to Rome immediately. (I have been there once, more than 30 years ago now, but don’t remember seeing the fountain.)
1. Someone to Watch Over Me (Young at Heart, 1954): I also love the title song, but Sinatra’s performance of this Gershwin standard in a bar, with annoying customers talking and laughing over him, is even better. He has two more great torch songs in the same film, One For My Baby and Just One of Those Things.
Must also mention that I love Monique, the song by Sammy Cahn and Elmer Bernstein which never got included in Kings Go Forth (1958), as I mentioned in my previous review.